Do We Still Need Teachers?

I feel the need to write a post to clear up some misinterpretations of my words. You see, nearly a month ago I was asked to speak to the staff at my school about how I am using iPads and technology in my classroom. I chose to talk about how I use Moodle to create a blended learning environment. I talked about how I record video lessons and share them using Moodle. I talked about how I create my own textbook using CK-12 and share it electronically using Moodle. I talked about how I am able to differentiate instruction for all the individual learners in my classroom. And, I talked about how I assess learning using electronic quizzes through the Moodle interface.

Although my presentation was limited to a very short amount of time (I could have talked for two or three days), I was happy to stir-up some conversation amongst the staff. Some teachers were open and ready to try new things with the technology in their classrooms, while others were hesitant and not ready for that kind of change. I'm not here to judge either side. I wasn't there to try to persuade teachers to try blended learning; I was there to share one story from inside one classroom in our high school.

However, recently I've heard some concerning conversations. I've heard teachers ("inspired" by my presentation) who are concerned about the future of education and the teaching profession. A few teachers are envisioning a classroom with a 100:1 student/teacher ratio. They are concerned that technology is replacing the need for a teacher.

I want to be very clear that I envision the teacher of the future to be valued MORE, and play a MORE important role in student learning!

Look, I understand the concern. The role of teachers is definitely changing! One-hundred years ago students HAD to come to school in order to learn. There were very few books, nearly no libraries, and limited newspapers and magazines. Teachers were the source of nearly all information. Teachers were the gate keeper to knowledge. 

However, technology has changed the educational landscape! Teachers are not the sole source of information now. Students have 24/7 access to unlimited amounts of information. Instead of relying on a teacher with limited training, students have access to industry experts who have devoted their entire life to studying very specific disciplines. The incredible knowledge that is available for FREE with a few clicks of the mouse (or finger) is mind blowing. It's impossible for me to wrap my brain around the ways our educational landscape has changed over the last 100 years! Yet, for the most part, the structure of our schools has remained nearly unchanged. It's no wonder our students are feeling let down, bored, and disengaged with school today. I can see how teachers could feel threatened. 

I hope my story can spread a message of hope to teachers feeling threatened. As I have integrated more and more technology into my classroom, I have never felt more valued and essential to my students' learning! Although I can share information with thousands of students simultaneously, skilled teachers are needed to draw meaning to that information; teachers will always be needed to bring that information to life for students. To borrow words from my friend Ginger Lewman, I have adapted the mindset that I am a resource, not THE source to my students. I push my students to search and discover information rather than passively receiving information. I want my students to find meaning in their life rather than me telling them what's important to them. I push my students to grow individually to reach their potential rather than push them collectively over an arbitrary hurdle. All of these roles are different, but FAR more important than the giver of information. These important roles need to happen on a one-to-one level; it cannot happen on a mass scale.  For this reason, I have a hopeful vision of the future of our teaching profession!

Our students no longer need teachers to feed them information, the information is at their fingertips. Instead our students need help making sence of information, help finding meaning, help making connections, and help digging deeper. Computers and technology will never be able to do this as effectively and magically as I can. The perfectly placed question, the balance between pushing hard but not breaking, the emotional connection, the stern look, and the deserved celebrations are all artistic touches that only a human can paint into a lesson. These are the pieces that engage students in learning. They are invaluable! 

Although technology could make it feasible for one teacher to manage 100 students; it will never happen. As long as our society values learning (which will be forever), the human teacher will be too valuable to spread across 100 students. 

WARNING: If you are a teacher, and you still believe that your only job is to feed students information, then you don't have to wait for the future; your job has already been replaced by technology. Sure, you may still receive a paycheck, but your days are numbered. I would urge you to loosen your grip on the control of the information, and encourage your students interact and engage with the information all around them.

We live in an exciting time of great innovation and technological advances. My mind cannot conceive the great technological advances we will see over the next hundred years, but my heart assures me that the future will be lead by great human teachers!